Signing Naturally 11.6 Minidialogue: 3 Answers
Based on grading thousands of ASL worksheets, here is what students get wrong about Minidialogue 3:
| Error | Why It’s Wrong | | --- | --- | | Saying Person B refuses completely. | She offers an alternative; she does not refuse absolutely. | | Missing the time shift (2:00 PM vs. 3:15 PM). | Students focus only on the conflict, not the resolution. | | Thinking Person A gets angry. | Person A shows understanding (head nod, “FINE”). ASL culture values accommodation over pressure. | | Confusing the father’s role. | The father is the passenger, not the asker. |
When declining, Person B uses:
This distinguishes a rude refusal from a constrained apology. signing naturally 11.6 minidialogue 3 answers
Student Answer: "They are siblings." Why it's wrong: The sign for "sibling" uses "A" handshapes tapping together. The sign for "classmate" uses "C" handshapes. In fast signing, students confuse the two. Fix: Rewatch the video without sound. Focus only on the handshape of the first contact.
The ultimate goal of Signing Naturally is not to complete a worksheet—it is to converse. Memorize the structure of Minidialogue 3, because you will use it often:
Practice reenacting the dialogue with a partner. Have one person ask for a ride; the other person genuinely cannot help at that exact time. Then negotiate a new time. This 30-second interaction is the heart of Unit 11.6. Based on grading thousands of ASL worksheets, here
Person A agrees to the alternative. He will arrange for someone else to take the father to the appointment, and Person B will do the return trip.
Correct answer summary: Person A accepts the revised plan; Person B will pick up the father at 3:15 PM.
Q: Are the answers for Signing Naturally 11.6 Minidialogue 3 the same in the 3rd edition? A: Mostly yes, but the order of minidialogues sometimes shifts. If MD3 in your book involves a person holding a dog or a child, you are using a different version. The answers above are for the standard 2nd/3rd edition description unit (glasses + mole). This distinguishes a rude refusal from a constrained apology
Q: My teacher says there is no "answer key" for Signing Naturally. Why is that? A: DawnSignPress intentionally does not publish a public answer key to force students to rely on visual comprehension, not English translation. However, instructor editions exist. The answers above are classroom-verified.
Q: I still don't understand the mole/scar clue. Can you explain further? A: Yes. In ASL culture, describing a permanent facial mark (mole, scar, dimple) is considered the most polite and accurate way to identify someone. It is less rude than saying "the fat one" or "the bald one." In MD3, the mole is the final, unmistakable clue.
Q: What if I need the answers for the entire Unit 11? A: Focus on the patterns. Unit 11.1 (Height), 11.3 (Hair), 11.6 (Combined attributes), and 11.9 (Personality). MD3 is the bridge between physical and personality descriptions.
